Gebruikersnaam:   Wachtwoord:   Gratis Registreren | Wachtwoord vergeten?
Rechtenforum.nl
Rechtenforum.nl Rechtenforum.nl
 
Controle paneel
Registreren Registreren
Agenda Agenda
Help Help
Zoeken Zoeken
Inloggen Inloggen

Partners
Energie vergelijken
Internet vergelijken
Hypotheekadviseur
Q Scheidingsadviseurs
Vergelijk.com

Rechtsbronnen
Rechtspraak
Kamervragen
Kamerstukken
AMvBs
Beleidsregels
Circulaires
Koninklijke Besluiten
Ministeriële Regelingen
Regelingen PBO/OLBB
Regelingen ZBO
Reglementen van Orde
Rijkskoninklijke Besl.
Rijkswetten
Verdragen
Wetten Overzicht

Wettenbundel
Awb - Algm. w. best...
AWR - Algm. w. inz...
BW Boek 1 - Burg...
BW Boek 2 - Burg...
BW Boek 3 - Burg...
BW Boek 4 - Burg...
BW Boek 5 - Burg...
BW Boek 6 - Burg...
BW Boek 7 - Burg...
BW Boek 7a - Burg...
BW Boek 8 - Burg...
FW - Faillissement...
Gemw - Gemeente...
GW - Grondwet
KW - Kieswet
PW - Provinciewet
WW - Werkloosheid...
Wbp - Wet bescherm...
IB - Wet inkomstbel...
WAO - Wet op de arb..
WWB - W. werk & bij...
RV - W. v. Burgerlijk...
Sr - W. v. Strafrecht
Sv - W. v. Strafvor...

Visie
Werkgevers toch ...
Waarderingsperik...
Het verschonings...
Indirect discrim...
Een recht op ide...
» Visie insturen

Rechtennieuws.nl
Loods mag worden...
KPN bereikt akko...
Van der Steur wi...
AKD adviseert de...
Kneppelhout beno...
» Nieuws melden

Snellinks
EUR
OUNL
RuG
RUN
UL
UM
UU
UvA
UvT
VU
Meer links

Rechtenforum
Over Rechtenforum
Maak favoriet
Maak startpagina
Mail deze site
Link naar ons
Colofon
Meedoen
Feedback
Contact

Recente topics
VA loan rates ...
180-dagen rege...
reparatiehuwel...
Res Nullius ?
proces verbaal...

Carrière
Boekel De Nerée
CMS DSB

Content Syndication


 
Het is nu do 28 mrt 2024 23:30
Bekijk onbeantwoorde berichten

Tijden zijn in GMT + 2 uur

Question regarding deposit when leaving shared flat
Moderator: Moderator Team

 
Plaats nieuw bericht   Plaats reactie Pagina 1 van 1
Printvriendelijk | E-mail vriend(in) Vorige onderwerp | Volgende onderwerp  
Auteur Bericht
Artur1338



Leeftijd: 25
Geslacht: Man
Sterrenbeeld: Steenbok
Studieomgeving (BA): UM

Berichten: 2


BerichtGeplaatst: zo 25 okt 2020 17:48    Onderwerp: Question regarding deposit when leaving shared flat Reageer met quote Naar onder Naar boven

Hey,

I am sorry that I am currently writing in English but maybe you guys can help me out on this issue.

Lets say Person A rents a room in a shared flat.
Now Person A cancels his contract and wants to move out of the room. When the landlord checks if the room is fine he finds some discolor on one wall and another.
This was likely caused by mould or something like that ( the spot was hidden by furniture and there are now some stains ) the damage is visible not not very big. Light yellow stains in an area of maybe 30cm x 30cm on both walls. This isn't very visible and even when Person A tried to Photograph it, it was barely visible on the picture.

Now the landlord wants Person A to pay the cost of fixing this spots. Person A is fine with it. The landlord then said that when he only fixes the little spot, then the wall would look repainted with a hard break between the colors so he has to repaint the whole wall.

It seems weird to me that Person A has to pay for the whole wall 2,8mx4m so around 12qm only because a small 30x30 cm spot is slightly discolored?

Is there any regulation regarding this ? Does Person A need to pay for this or is the landlord responsible for that ?

Regards Artur
Bekijk profiel Stuur privé bericht
bona fides




Geslacht: Man

Studieomgeving (BA): UL
Studieomgeving (MA): UL
Berichten: 22889


BerichtGeplaatst: zo 25 okt 2020 21:24    Onderwerp: Reageer met quote Naar onder Naar boven

In general, small repairs that a tenant can in principle carry out him/herself are the responsbility of the tenant, bigger repairs are the responsbility of the landlord.

https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/onderwerpen/huurwoning/vraag-en-antwoord/onderhoud-huurwoning
"Witten van binnenmuren" is listed as a small repair.

According to article 7:217 BW, the tenant is obliged to carry out the small repairs at his cost (unless the landlord is somehow to blame for them).

According to article 224, paragraph 2, BW, the tenant is obliged to return the rented property in its original state apart from permitted changes and additions and what I would call natural degradation ("hetgeen door ouderdom is teniet gegaan of beschadigd").

The original state is supposed to have been put on paper when the tenant received the keys. If that was never done, it is up to the landlord to prove that the property is not in its original state.

My personal opinion on the legal situation:
If there are clear stains on the wall ("damage" as you call it yourself), it seems fair that the cost of their repair is for the (leaving) tenant.
However, I'm not convinced that the tenant is obliged to pay for a perfectly white wall. Even if the description of the original state mentions that the walls were freshly painted, it is normal that this is no longer the case after several years of use. In my view a non-perfectly white wall is not a small defect that needs to be repaired (and one can wonder whether a perfect paint job is a "small repair" that can be carried out by the tenant himself without hiring a professional painter).

In my experience, it is customary in The Netherlands that the walls are simply left to the next tenant in whatever state they are. (But with mould spots this may be different. Of course mould could also point to a bigger problem for which the landlord is then responsible.)
_________________
Hanc marginis exiguitas non caperet.
Bekijk profiel Stuur privé bericht
Artur1338



Leeftijd: 25
Geslacht: Man
Sterrenbeeld: Steenbok
Studieomgeving (BA): UM

Berichten: 2


BerichtGeplaatst: zo 25 okt 2020 22:03    Onderwerp: Reageer met quote Naar onder Naar boven

Thanks for the answer.
I am not sure what exactly this is.
https://i.imgur.com/MYzDyyr.jpg

Let see how much he wants and then I will see if I need to take action.
As for now, there is nothing that I can do as the landlord has the money and will return how much he thinks he owns me.

If he returns to less money then the only way would be a lawsuit in court for maybe 100€ or something that he's gonna take.
Bekijk profiel Stuur privé bericht
Berichten van afgelopen:   
Plaats nieuw bericht   Plaats reactie Pagina 1 van 1

Tijden zijn in GMT + 2 uur


Wie zijn er online?
Leden op dit forum: Geen

U mag geen nieuwe onderwerpen plaatsen
U mag geen reacties plaatsen
U mag uw berichten niet bewerken
U mag uw berichten niet verwijderen
U mag niet stemmen in polls

Ga naar:  



Home | Over Rechtenforum.nl | Agenda | Visie | Downloads | Links | Mail deze site | Contact

Sites: Rechtennieuws.nl | Jure.nl | Maxius.nl | Parlis.nl | Rechtenforum.nl | Juridischeagenda.nl | Juridica.nl | MijnWetten.nl | AdvocatenZoeken.nl

© 2003 - 2018 Rechtenforum.nl | Gebruiksvoorwaarden | Privacyverklaring | RSS feeds